Stephen Miller’s Use of White Nationalist Rhetoric to Hijack the Moments that Call for Speech
Research on Stephen Miller’s address at Charlie Kirk’s memorial suggests that white nationalist speakers use nearly any public occasion to promote fears of racial replacement.

01 — Research Summary
Introduction
This month, Stephen Miller, previously the White House deputy chief of staff for policy, began serving as President Trump’s chief of staff following the 2026 midterm elections, in which Democrats won control of both chambers of Congress. As one of the most powerful positions at the top of the U.S. government, the chief of staff role influences policy and messaging and, as a result, impacts the lives of people around the world.
In light of Miller’s promotion, this month’s NCA Amplified is highlighting a recent analysis of Miller’s rhetoric by Casey R. Kelly, published in Communication and Democracy. “White House Chief of Staff Stephen Miller is arguably the most powerful white nationalist sympathizer in the Trump Administration,” Kelly told NCA. “He is the architect of some of the administration’s cruelest and most dehumanizing policies, including mass detention and deportations.”
The essay is a close reading of Miller’s address at the September 2025 memorial for Charlie Kirk, the founder of Turning Point USA (TPUSA), who was shot and killed on September 10, 2025, while speaking at a TPUSA event at Utah Valley University. Kelly describes Kirk as a far-right provocateur who promoted conspiracy theories about racial replacement. Through his examination, Kelly illustrates how white nationalists like Miller manipulate rhetorical exigences to support the extremist conspiracy theory that white people are being threatened and “replaced” by people of color. Kelly compares Miller’s speech to a 1932 address by Nazi propagandist Joseph Goebbels. In both speeches, the speaker presents a member of the movement who has been killed as a martyr whose death should inspire followers to rise up against their enemies.
Rethinking the Rhetorical Exigence
“Exigence,” in rhetorical analysis like Kelly’s, refers to the urgent events that call on someone to speak. Kelly draws on Lloyd Bitzer’s 1968 essay “The Rhetorical Situation,” which defined an exigence as “an imperfection marked by urgency.” According to Bitzer, each exigence invites a “fitting response” based on what the audience expects and the constraints of the situation. A death calls for a eulogy, for example, and people attending a memorial expect the speakers to reflect on the loss and help them grieve.
Kelly argues that white nationalist speakers approach exigences differently. They understand what an occasion asks of them, but deliberately refuse to respond appropriately. Instead, they treat nearly every event as a sign of “another, hidden exigence,” namely the supposed threat of “white genocide.” Kelly asks if rhetorical scholars should reconsider how they think about exigence at a time when demagogues regularly manipulate public occasions to divide audiences.
Four Features of the White Nationalist Exigence
First, according to Kelly, white nationalist rhetoric separates exigence from the expectations that usually guide public speech in a democracy. Drawing on Lauren Berlant, Kelly connects this behavior to “Big Man” sovereignty, a form of white masculine authority based on the feeling of being unconstrained.
Second, white nationalists interpret exigences in what Kelly calls an “anti-rhetorical” way. Rhetoric rests on the idea that events can have multiple meanings. White nationalists replace this uncertainty with absolute certainty, because to them adapting to a situation would require vulnerability and openness to others.
Third, white nationalists present information as timely and urgent, while insisting their interpretation of events is the only correct one. Kelly notes that in a fragmented culture, it is harder for people to agree on what is urgent, allowing speakers to adapt the occasion to their message instead of adapting their message to the occasion. He compares this to so-called “settler exigencies,” in which colonial interests take priority over what Indigenous people consider urgent.
Finally, white nationalists read exigence through the lens of necropolitics, philosopher Achille Mbembe’s term for power organized around death and deciding whose lives have value. To white nationalists like Miller, any event can be understood as evidence of a plot to destroy white civilization and as part of a coming racial civil war. Kelly uses Mbembe’s term “death worlds” to describe the fantasies of control over life and death that result.
Three Shifts in Miller’s Address
According to Kelly, Miller’s speech deserves attention “neither for its eloquence nor originality,” but because of the power Miller holds. Following rhetorical critic Edwin Black, Kelly analyzes the speech by asking what it would have its audience do, think, or become. He identifies three shifts in Miller’s speech that move the exigence from Kirk’s death to the supposed death of Western civilization: from personal to impersonal motives, from the memorial as a single moment to a long view of history, and from an affirmation of life to a celebration of death.
Fire and Storms
Miller told the crowd that “the day that Charlie died the angels wept” and those tears had been “turned into fire in our hearts.” The audience had gathered to mourn Kirk, but Miller added a second purpose, which was “to dedicate ourselves to finishing his mission and achieving victory in his name.” Kelly argues that mourning served as a pretext for this second goal, turning grief into a sense of grievance. Referring to Kirk’s widow, Erika Kirk, Miller declared, “Erika is the storm. We are the storm.” Kelly adds that storm imagery is common in fascist and white nationalist movements. In this context, describing a movement as a storm signals a willingness to use violence against political enemies.
A Mythic History
Miller also placed Kirk’s death within an idealized and whitewashed history of Western civilization, saying, “Our lineage and our legacy hails back to Athens, to Rome, to Philadelphia, to Monticello.” Kelly argues that this framing treats American identity as a birthright inherited from Europe and ignores the fact that the nation was built on the labor of enslaved people and the dispossession of Indigenous lands.
“You Are Nothing”
Miller then turned to an unnamed “you,” saying, “You are nothing. You are wickedness. You are jealousy.” Kelly argues that describing opponents as wickedness or hatred itself, rather than as people who did something wrong, strips them of their humanity. Notably, Miller never named the shooter or any group he held responsible. According to Kelly, this ambiguity creates a flexible enemy that could include anyone who criticizes, questions, or stands outside of Western civilization.
Conclusion: The Weakness Behind the Storm
Kelly concludes that white nationalists like Miller take advantage of rhetorical situations and manufacture crises as a pretext for repressive ethnonationalist policies. His analysis also points to weaknesses in white nationalist rhetoric. The false image of an unstoppable storm hides how fragile the belief system behind it actually is. White nationalists’ mythic version of Western history, from ancient Rome to the present day, “is easily debunked” with facts. Their celebration of death also contradicts the language of heritage and tradition they claim to defend. According to Kelly, white nationalism has to hijack public debate and prey on fears of annihilation “precisely because it is weaker than pluralism, empathy, and equality.”
Instead of responding on white nationalists’ terms, Kelly suggests countering the grievances they stir up by focusing on other pressing needs, building solidarity across differences, and being willing to deal with complexity. As he writes, “life-affirming empathy and conviviality” are preferable to “death-conjuring nihilism.”
02 — Key Applications
- Introduce rhetorical analysis earlier. Students can learn to ask what an occasion calls for (e.g., a memorial, a graduation, a press conference) and to notice when a speaker uses that occasion for a different purpose.
- Teach students to ask the question Kelly borrows from rhetorical critic Edwin Black: What would this speech have me do, think, or become?
- When speeches reference history, teach the history alongside them. For example, Miller’s reference to Monticello takes on a different meaning once students learn that more than 600 people were enslaved there.
- Help students recognize dehumanizing language, such as describing people as “wickedness” or “nothing” instead of as individuals responsible for specific actions.
- Discuss how certain words and symbols (such as “storm”) can carry coded meanings for some audiences.
- Practice tolerating ambiguity, disagreeing respectfully, and working through complex problems in the classroom.
- Study analyses like Kelly’s to better understand how Miller might communicate as White House chief of staff.
- Be aware of crises being used as a pretext for policy.
- When calls for “emergency measures” follow a tragedy, ask what specific problem the measures would address and who would be affected.
- Respond to these messages by addressing constituents’ actual needs, not focusing only on rebuttals.
- Support civic and communication education, including rhetorical analysis, in schools, libraries, and other public institutions.
- Move beyond the premise of white nationalist arguments. When a speaker frames a tragedy as proof of a larger conflict between civilizations, report that framing as a claim, not as context.
- Report on the occasion as well as the speech. Note when remarks at a memorial, vigil, or ceremony depart from the event’s purpose.
- When a speaker attacks an unnamed “you” or “our enemies,” ask who that refers to. As Kelly shows, leaving the enemy unnamed allows blame to extend to anyone who disagrees.
- Be careful about repeating loaded metaphors such as “storm,” “fire,” “the West,” or “civilization” in headlines without explaining how they are being used.
- Avoid framing a political movement’s success as inevitable.
- Be wary of administration communications about events designed for media coverage, such as memorials, vigils, and ceremonies. Compare the stated purpose of an event with how speakers actually use it.
- When advising organizations responding to a tragedy, make sure the response fits the occasion and focuses first on the people affected.
- Avoid militaristic or elemental metaphors (storms, fire, war) and “us vs. them” language in your own messaging, since these can contribute to polarization.
- Prepare for the possibility that others will reframe your organization’s statements, events, or crises, and plan how to restate your purpose clearly.
- If your organization responds publicly to coded language, explain what it means in plain terms without amplifying the original message.
- Make sure community vigils and memorials remain focused on mourning and on the people affected.
- Bring attention to local needs that bring people together across differences.
- Host public conversations and forums that encourage openness to complexity and respectful disagreement.
- Partner with local historians, libraries, and museums to share more complete accounts of local and national history, including slavery and the dispossession of Indigenous lands.
- Design outreach programs that combine empathy with accountability, as Kelly recommends, when engaging people who may be drawn to white nationalist messages.
03 — Citation and Link to Study
Kelly, C. R. (2026). The white nationalist exigence: Stephen Miller and the rhetoric of racial replacement. Communication and Democracy, 60(2), 319–338. https://doi.org/10.1080/27671127.2026.2709624
Bitzer, L. F. (1968). The rhetorical situation. Philosophy & Rhetoric, 1(1), 1–14.
